Pick your pleasure
When Aunt Mae would lovingly make up her special batches of Toffee on those wintry Christmas Eves so many years ago – who would have thought that any other flavor could compete with her delightfully delicious treats?
And yet, Aunt Mae’s Sweet Tooth has created, taste-tested and perfected three new Toffee flavors that rival our classic Toffee for rich, rewarding goodness.
We think you’ll have difficult time deciding which is your favorite.
Candy Cane Toffee
Our Holiday Candy Cane Toffee is back!!! Our White Chocolate English Toffee sprinkled with chopped Candy Canes! The most festive gift and treat for this Holiday season! Only available through November & December, so order now!
8oz / $18.00
16oz / $36.00
Caramel Toffee
Caramel Toffee! It starts with a thick layer of Aunt Mae’s gourmet English Toffee. We then pour an equal amount of our heavy, house made caramel on top of our toffee! This is the same caramel we use on our apples. Both sides are layered with milk chocolate and locally grown chopped almonds. It’s by far our richest flavor yet. Crunchy toffee meets soft caramel. The flavor and sensation will raise your eyebrows. 4 ounces won’t be enough. Our Caramel Toffee is decadence defined.
4oz / $8.00
8oz / $18.00
16oz / $36.00
Pretzel Toffee
Aunt Mae’s Gourmet English Toffee poured onto salty pretzels. Pretzels of all kinds: Twists, sticks, & rods! Layered with dark chocolate and sprinkled with locally grown Chopped almonds. A sweet, salty treat. When you open this bag you will not be able to stop. Aunt Mae’s Pretzel Toffee!
5oz / $7.00
Rocky Road Toffee
Walnuts & pecans are inside of our gourmet English Toffee. A layer of marshmallow follows with milk chocolate, and topped with chopped almonds! All of the Nuts used are grown locally. The combination of nuts with our crunchy toffee and soft marshmallows underneath milk chocolate creates an amazing savor. It’s another great Aunt Mae flavor you must enjoy. Rocky Road Toffee!
S’mores & Toffee
Imagine S’mores and Aunt Mae’s gourmet English Toffee. Marshmallows melted inside of our toffee. Layered with graham crackers, Hershey’s milk chocolate, chopped graham crackers, and then topped with Teddy Grahams. Yes, it’s a lot to take in. You get a soft & crunchy texture. The taste of traditional S’mores with Aunt Mae’s sensational Toffee!
Nutty Toffee
Aunt Mae’s gourmet English Toffee & Peanuts. No chocolate. Just peanuts and toffee. It doesn’t get any more simple than that. Aunt Mae’s version of Peanut Brittle. Salty peanuts & our rich toffee make for one delicious treat!
Peanut Toffee
Aunt Mae’s gourmet English Toffee & Peanuts. No chocolate. Just peanuts and toffee. It doesn’t get any more simple than that. Aunt Mae’s version of Peanut Brittle. Salty peanuts & our rich toffee make for one delicious treat!
Bacon Toffee
Bacon Toffee! We bake thick Applewood bacon until it is slightly crisp. After chopping the bacon into small chunks, we then pour our gourmet Toffee on the chunks. Add Milk Chocolate and chopped almonds, and you have a simple yet tasteful treat. The firm English Toffee and the chewy bacon combined produce a savoring flavor. This variety of English Toffee costs slightly more due to the bacon.
Flamin’ Cheeto Toffee!
Flamin’ Hot Cheetos covered in our gourmet English Toffee. No chocolate, and no nuts. Just Cheetos and toffee! Spicy and sweet. Eye popping flavor. Don’t believe me.. well then, I suggest you try it.
Toffee Rice Krispie Treats
Our soft gooey Rice Krispie Treats are filled with toffee bits! The English Toffee makes our large Rice Krispie Treats better than the rest!
Circus Animal Toffee
We put Circus Animal cookies in the center of our gourmet toffee. White chocolate spread on both sides of the toffee. Circus Animal cookies on one side, and sprinkles on the opposite side. Warning: this taste is extremely sweet!
Churro Oreo toffee
Very simple, we took Aunt Mae’s Churro Toffee then added a Vanilla Oreo to the center. Like our Churro Toffee, we coated each side with white chocolate, and then sprinkled it with the right amount of cinnamon and sugar. This Churro Oreo Toffee actually tastes like a Churro. The Vanilla Oreo gives softness and more flavor to the crunchy toffee. Add our cinnamon and sugar combination and you get a very distinctive and familiar taste. This flavor will leave a great impression..
Churro toffee
Imagine Aunt Mae’s gourmet English Toffee with the flavor of a Churro. Our gourmet toffee coated with white chocolate, then sprinkled with just the right amount of cinnamon and sugar. Simple and delicious, the way life is supposed to be. Order now! .
Coconut Golden Oreo
Coconut Golden Oreo is Aunt Mae’s gourmet English Toffee with a Vanilla Oreo in the middle. On one side of this flavor are melted Mounds candy bars covered with chopped almonds. The other side has bright white sweetened coconut atop of dark chocolate. I know, it’s a lot to take in. The taste is nothing less than amazing! .
Classic Toffee
Hand-crafted in small batches, this is the original Aunt Mae recipe made every Christmas Eve and treasured by family and friends alike. A rich, buttery Toffee base coated with a layer of sweet chocolate and sprinkle-coated with chopped, locally grown, finest-quality California almonds.
Dark Chocolate Toffee with Sea Salt
Aunt Mae’s gourmet English Toffee with Dark Chocolate and Sea Salt. A bold kick of luscious dark chocolate flavor will make this variation of the Classic Aunt Mae’s Toffee creation an instant favorite with hard-core chocolate lovers. Every batch is hand crafted and sprinkled with locally grown, California chopped almonds. This bitter yet salty taste will have you ordering more! Packaging changes seasonally according to upcoming holidays. Order Aunt Mae’s Dark Chocolate Toffee with Sea Salt now!
White Chocolate Toffee
Classic Aunt Mae’s Toffee gets a sweet new look and taste when we add rich and creamy White Chocolate. Order extra, this one will go fast!
Peanut Butter Crunch Toffee
Aunt Mae’s Peanut Butter Crunch Toffee is a peanut butter lover’s dream! Our classic milk chocolate English Toffee with a layer of peanut butter mixed with more milk chocolate! And now, in the middle of our crunchy toffee base are Peanut Butter Cookies!
8oz / $17.50
Oreo Toffee
This is Aunt Mae’s NEW Oreo Toffee. It’s our traditional milk chocolate English Toffee with whole Oreos in the middle. Every batch is hand made with all natural ingredients. We grow and harvest our chopped almonds from our commercial farm. We use an entire package of Oreo’s in every produced batch. Oreo Toffee!! Our most creative flavor yet!! Custom orders can be produced with dark or white chocolate.
24K Toffee
24 k Toffee is Aunt Mae’s newest creation. Here, we have replaced our chocolate with the New Hershey’s Gold bar. In every batch we use sixteen Hershey’s Gold bars, creating a yellow brightness and a rich buttery sensation of flavor. You will taste the value in this toffee. 24k Toffee is our chefs’ favorite flavor thus far.
Variety Pack
Pieces of our Milk, White, & Dark Chocolate English Toffee.
30oz / $65.00
6oz / $10.00